Current Conditions


Signature look leads to arson conviction

March 02, 2015 - 7:30 PM

KAMLOOPS – The video evidence may have been grainy, but it was an accused man’s white Stetson cowboy hat that turned his arson charge into a conviction.

Kamloops Provincial Court Judge Stephen Harrison convicted Mannie Shaw Stewart of arson damaging the McCracken Station Pub’s property after reviewing video evidence of the event and hearing from two witnesses who recognized the accused.

On May 13, 2013 a surveillance camera caught Stewart lighting garbage on fire in the alleyway between the Valleyview pub and its neighbouring liquor store.

The video, which was played in court Monday, March 2, showed the profile of a shorter man wearing a white hat, jeans and white sneakers as he approached a garbage can near the door of the pub and threw something in it. When the man walked away, visible flames grew from the can.

Kevin Tibbett, the kitchen manager of the pub, said after dousing the flames he went to ask Michael Wu, the liquor store attendant, to review the surveillance footage.

“Both Michael and I knew who it was immediately,” Tibbett said. He added the accused regularly attended the pub and always wore a white cowboy hat. “It’s his signature. It’s what he always wore.”

Stewart's lawyer, Richard Kaiser, argued there was no property loss to the pub because it was trash released for collection. He asked for a mischief charge instead of arson.

Harrison rejected Kaiser’s argument because the contents of the garbage can were not transferred to a neighbouring dumpster. But he accepted the hat identified Stewart and found him guilty.

He ordered a pre-sentence report and a return date of April 2 to fix a date for sentencing.

To contact a reporter for this story, email, or call 250-319-7494. To contact the editor, email or call 250-718-2724.

News from © InfoTel News Ltd, 2015
InfoTel News Ltd

  • Popular penticton News
  • Comments
  • Body of missing Cache Creek fire chief found
    CACHE CREEK - The body of Clayton Cassidy has been found. Around 10:30 p.m. yesterday, May 27, members of the Ashcroft fire department found his body during a patrol of Cache Creek, accordin
  • TRENDING NOW: Instant karma for angry dog walker
    When crossing a street we all pay attention to a car pulling up to an intersection, but this man seems to get really riled up for some reason. Of course, his threatening behaviour is under c
  • Firefighters rescue unexpected visitors during blaze battle in Calgary
    Calgary firefighters made an unexpected rescue when they were battling a house fire in the city's southwest. On Friday afternoon, a passerby called 911 to report smoking coming from a ho
  • Fire on Front Street
    PENTICTON - Penticton firefighters spent a hot afternoon battling a fire on Front Street today. Penticton Deputy Fire Chief Chris Forester said in a release Sunday evening, May 28, firefight
  • No, Okanagan Lake will not peak this weekend
    If you’re confused about projections for what Okanagan Lake is going to do over the next few weeks, you’re not alone. The City of Penticton issued a media release yesterday, May
View Site in: Desktop | Mobile