Current Conditions


Coroner to investigate death of a Summerland senior

December 10, 2012 - 3:44 PM

UPDATE: Dec. 13 - 4:52 p.m.

The B.C. Coroners Service has an open file on Marie Louisa Bonaldi who died three months before husband Alfredo Bonaldi was found close to death at the same retirement home.

Coroner Barb McLintock says the file was never closed and the investigation continues into the deaths of both Bonaldi family members living at Summerland Senior's Village. She adds that Mrs. Bonaldi died as the result of a fall where she suffered a fracture, and all non-natural deaths are investigated.

"Obviously we're going to look into these, but they're the same as any other death," says McLintock. "We want to determine who, when and where and offer any recommendations that can reasonably prevent future deaths in similar circumstances. We never lay blame and we never lay fault."

Stay with us as more information from the coroners service as the investigation continues.


UPDATE: Dec. 11 - 8:56 a.m.

The B.C. Coroner's Service has confirmed it's investigating the death of a 91-year-old man who died Dec. 7 after family members found him seriously ill at a Summerland retirement home.

Alfredo Bonaldi, an independent resident of Summerland Senior's Village was admitted Nov. 25 in medical distress and died late in the evening last Friday at Penticton Regional Hospital.

The hospital reported the death to the B.C. Coroner's Service, but Coroner Barbara McLintock said in a press release it's too early to comment on reports of potential problems arising from Bonaldi's stay at Summerland care home.

The B.C. Coroner's Service conducts fully indpendent investigations into all unnatural, unexpected deaths in the province. The investigation will be concluded either by a Coroner's Report that will be available to the public, or possibly by the calling of a public inquest at which time sworn evidence in the case would be heard by a jury.

In either case, the mandate of Coroners Service is not to find fault or lay blame, but it may make recommendations to try to prevent future deaths in similar circumstances.

UPDATE: Dec. 10 - 3:21 p.m.

The man said to be neglected at a Summerland retirement home has died.

Alfredo Bonaldi was rushed to hospital after his family discovered him near-death in his room at Summerland Senior's Village. Bonaldi, who occupied a residence for independent  seniors missed meals in the dining room for days and staff failed to check in on him to find out why.

Retirement Concepts, owner of Summerland Senior's Village and 18 retirement homes across Canada accepted responsibility saying a breakdown in communication resulted in 91-year-old Bonaldi being ignored and have since formalized their communication process.

Bonaldi has been battling a variety of illnesses including kidney failure since the incident and died Friday night, according to a Global BC news article.

Dec. 4 - 12:04 p.m.

"We're sick and tired of hearing they're working on this. They (policies) should be in place before they go into business."

A Summerland retirement home is being investigated and monitored after a series of complaints of neglect, most recently from one family whose mother suffered for weeks in pain before dying and their father was found near death last week.
Family discovered 91-year-old Alfredo Bonaldi in his room at Summerland Seniors Village suffering from kidney failure Sunday. He is now on life support at Penticton Regional Hospital. They later discovered he was missing from meal time for as long as three days and staff didn't follow up on absence reports to check on him. This after Bonaldi's wife, Maria Louisa, died there three months earlier under troubling circumstances.
The family didn't go public with their mom's death, but after suffering yet again with the same home, they want to see changes.
"Really? You don't know (where he is and) you don't pick up a phone?" says daughter Edi Inglis. "He has three daughters here in town and they have spouses. They have home numbers and cells. If that doesn't work, go down and figure out why he's not at dinner."
Retirement Concepts, the company that operates the home, accepts responsibility for not checking on Mr. Bonaldi, saying it was a breakdown in staff communication. 
President and CEO Azim Jamal says an internal investigation found that Bonaldi was reported absent but the message either wasn't received or wasn't acted upon by care staff. In response, they have formalized the communication process. Salmonella poisoning from the facility was all but ruled out as a cause of illness, as speculated by some news agencies.
Bonaldi was largely independent in the home so his absence wouldn't have created the same level of concern as other residents getting constant care, the company has said. Bonaldi also had an emergency response button in his suite, but never used it. Both of those factors will be under internal review but Retirement Concepts is now being investigated by both the Ministry of Health and Interior Health, which has placed a monitor on site after not just these but other recent complaints.
"We don't have to do this very often," says spokesperson Karen Bloemink. "We can't decide what our role in this will be until our investigation is complete. It's not an Interior Health facility."
Bonaldi's family, meanwhile, says they have heard all this before.
"They say they're working on policy and procedure. We're sick and tired of hearing they're working on this. They (policies) should be in place before they go into business," Inglis says.
Her family went through similar circumstances when their mother suffered weeks of pain before dying three months ago. She was in residential care with advanced Alzheimers. It was revealed that Louisa Bonaldi fell from a chair during a bath roughly one month before she died. The incident and several reports of pain were reported to doctors who ignored them and simply prescribed pain killers.
Almost a week later, doctors finally got x-rays and saw a broken femur.
The company says Interior Health reviewed the incident and found that staff were doing as they were told by the doctor and changes were made to bathing procedures.
Interior Health owns around 50 per cent of facilities in the region. Those facilities are operated, funded and managed by Interior Health. The other half is contracted out. Bloemink says Interior Health remains responsible for clinic services and management of dollars and making sure those facilities are delivering what they are required to deliver. Summerland is contracted out and Interior Health funds the facility to deliver care. 
Summerland Seniors Village is owned by Retirement Concepts who, according to their website, own two other facilities in the interior, 10 in the lower mainland, five on Vancouver Island with another in Quebec. They have no other facilities in development at this time.
News from © InfoTel News Ltd, 2012
InfoTel News Ltd

  • Popular kelowna News
  • Comments

View Site in: Desktop | Mobile